Home IGN.com Personalize IGN vMail eMail Win Stuff
★ wanayoo — archive 1999 http://scifi.ign.com/anime/4659.htmlNouvelle recherche | Portail wanayoo
IGN.com sponsor ad
 June 7, 2000



 



 


 Movies
 TV
 Comics
 Anime
 Toys
 Features
 Letters
 Ask The B.E.M.
 Chat
 Listings
 TV Grid


 IGN.com
 Movies
 ·FilmForce
 DVD
 IGNtv
 Wrestling
 Sci-Fi
 ·Comics
 ·Anime
 ·TV
 ForMen
 ·Babes
 ·Cars
 ·Gear
 ·Dating
 Codes &
 Cheats

 Game Guides

 Videogames
 ·N64
 ·PS2
 ·PSX
 ·Dreamcast
 ·Handhelds
 ·Xbox
 PC games
 ·RPG Vault
 ·Downloads
 Affiliates
 Chat

 Shopping
 ·Buy Games
 ·Drugstore
 ·Trading
 Career Zone
 Free MP3s
 Sponsors

My IGN
 Log In/
 Register

 IGN Mail
 IGN Link
 IGN Feedback
 Newsletter
 File Storage
 Free Internet

Help
 Site Map
 Site FAQ


 Sci-fi > anime > Gundam Wing, Tallgeese Destroyed


 Gundam Wing, Tallgeese Destroyed

review: The definition of "destroyed" ain't what it used to be.

June 7, 2000

Series
Gundam Wing
Episode
18: Tallgeese Destroyed
Airing Date
2000-03-29
Rerun Date
2000-06-06
Sci-fi Bits
Mobile Dolls gain respect within OZ.
Juicy Bits
The friendship between Zechs and Treize ends.
Featuring

Mark Hildereth as Heero Yuy
Scott McNeil as Duo Maxwell
Brian Drummond as Zechs Merquise
David Kaye as Treize Khushrenada
Ted Cole as Chang Wufei
Brad Swaile as Quatre Raebe Winner
Saffron Henderson as Lucrezia Noin
Lisa Ann Beley as Relena Peacecraft

Honor is one of the most revered concepts in the After Colony years. It’s what defines and unifies the men and women who fight in the Gundam Wing series, and it’s responsible for many of their actions, too.

Zechs Merquise (who’s actually Milliardo Peacecraft) and Treize Khushrenada have been friends and comrades a long time. Their dual sense of honor has kept them equals, even though Treize has risen to a singular position of importance within the ranks of OZ. Now, though, the two men must part ways. Destiny being what it is, Zechs cannot remain on Earth with Treize and OZ any longer. The tug of his own path is too strong.

"Tallgeese Destroyed" is a curious episode. Proud and full of original, interesting ideas, it’s also strangely hollow and leaves us wanting more. Yes, I’m aware of the first rule of storytelling -- "always leave your audience wanting more" -- but in this case I didn’t feel as if we were given enough to satisfy our Gundam Wing hunger in any real, concrete way. Maybe this type of episode is to be expected every few weeks or so -- the filler episode. The bridge. Now that the action is shifting away from Earth and toward Outer Space, there are a number of shifts (or scene changes) which need to be made so that all the players are in the new forum. "Tallgeese Destroyed," while not being light on story, somehow feels like a cheat.

While the higher-ups in the Romefeller Foundation are entranced with both the performance ratings and the business prospects of their newly released Mobile Dolls, Treize worries that a war fought without human beings has nothing to do with honor. He’s also concerned that his friend Zechs will be court-martialed unless he promises to rejoin the fight against the five Gundams.

The Zechs hatchling emerges from its shell.

Zechs cannot do that, though, and is told that OZ will dispatch a huge force of 50 Aries suits and 20 Cancers to destroy him and the ship he’s hiding on. Treize notifies Zechs, tells him of OZ’s plan in the hopes his friend will escape with his life. The battle begins, Zechs lays waste to the enemy and winds up passed out on a sandy beach alongside the Tallgeese. During the battle his ever-present mask shatters -- as it crumbles, Zechs proclaims his friendship with Treize over.

Again (because I’ve said this before), Zechs motivation here is foggy at best. Sure, you can read into it if you want, but I prefer to let each episode stand on its own. Treize has taken a great risk to allow his friend a chance at survival. Right now, Zechs’ path isn’t entirely clear. It’s not a foregone conclusion that Zechs and Treize will square off against each other. Yet the Gundam Wing producers (and writers) tip their hand by having Zechs formally end his friendship with Treize. Maybe it’s the Japanese custom of formality -- for me, though, it feels forced and obvious. Maybe the problem here isn’t that we’re left wanting more, but that "Tallgeese Destroyed" left us knowing too much.


--Ross Brooks will destroy you. Which means he'll send you to a beautiful, sandy beach.


3 out of 5




Past Gundam Wing Reviews

49: Final Victors
48: Take Off Into Confusion
47: Collision in Space
46: Milliardo's Decision
45: Signs of the Final Battle
44: Go Forth, Gundam Team
43: Target: Earth
42: Battleship Libra
41: Crossfire at Barge
40: A New Leader
39: Trowa Returns to the Battlefield
38: Relena Becomes Queen
37: Zero vs. Epyon
36: The Collapse of the Sanc Kingdom

17: Betrayed By Home, Faraway
16: The Sorrowful Battle
15: To the Battleground Antarctica
14: The Order to Destroy Zero One
13: Catherine's Tears
12: Bewildered Warriors
11: The Whereabouts of Happiness
10: Heero - Distracted by Defeat
9: Portrait of a Ruined Country
8: The Treize Assassination
7: Scenario of Bloodshed
6: Party Night
5: Relena's Secret
4: The Victorian Nightmare
3: Five Gundams Confirmed
2: Deathscythe
1: The Shooting Star She Saw

back to top | archive



June 28, 2000 - Headlines

Gundam Wing, The Lonely Battlefield - anime - 6.28.
Talking Star Trek - tv - 6.28.
Hitchhiker's Guide to the Movies - movies - 6.28.
The Week in Comics - comics - 6.28.



Sponsored Links










Copyright Snowball.com